I don't care about who voted or politically appointed this law, regulation, code, etc. I don't care for unnecessary ad hominem insults or generalizations from either sides but here we are. From my perspective, it is another example of humanity's arrogance in believing we are superior to nature/physics.
Before I continue, I can somewhat understand the perspective where RustVendor is coming from, or at least arguing on behalf of, although I think it is wrong and misguided. I do appreciate the contrarian, 10th man doctrine, and devils advocates. I think most would agree that having a minimum standard for tires enforced by a government entity is better and safer for the general public. RustVendor made an irrefutable point along the lines of, "it's worth it if the individual and the public at large benefit from holding manufacturer's to a higher standard." I can see it being worthwhile even if the individual savings are $180 spread across 4 years. With ALL things being equal by what ever date, a higher standard of quality at a lower cost is a good thing.
Unfortunately, this phrase "the road to hell is paved in good intentions" is suited perfectly for this. Correct me if I am wrong, but at least historically, harder compound tires have different advantages and disadvantages than sticky compound. It's basically a spectrum with harder "LRR" compounds good for MPG and with softer "sticky" compounds good for performance. Barring a novel super compound, this will likely result in hard tires across public us and will have unforeseen consequences. It is also an irrefutable point to state performance tire also has the potential to save more lives and avoid accidents compared to the harder compound. Remember performance is also about stopping or cornering quickly aka safety not just going fast. Will the increase of car accidents outweigh the savings from this tire program?
That is just the low hanging fruit and one facet of the problem. We haven't even spoken to the lack of public transit, the failure/corruption of high speed rail, or the horrific road conditions for these tires to survive. It seems awfully similar to Australia or Florida adding a foreign animal species into its native habitat while expecting only one specific result. You're a mad

if you think that (did I get that right?).