What do you think is the best all-around 9mm that is on the Roster?

[JohntheBaptized]

I think the PX4 Compact Carry, 1 or 2

 

[pancakes]

SO ive owned and tested every on roster pistol and a ton of off roster.
First question does 2Azone signel shots count?
If not then Echelon comps and 2.0

 

[Magnetic_FoST23]

Kinda surprised no one has said it so far, but I'd say undoubtedly the 365 XMacro comp. Big enough to be a good range gun/home defense gun, but small enough to be a very good ccw. Optic ready, decent enough trigger, good capacity, and near infinite aftermarket support. You can make it into a micro size pocket 9, or a metal frame 4.5" gun for competition. It really is a do everything gun.

This would be my vote (X Macro Comp).

 

[pancakes]

This would be my vote.

actually very fair

 

[AR15barrels]

First question does 2Azone signel shots count?

No.
Those are all off-roster guns.
Hence the need to re-manufacture and re-mark them as a different manufacturer to get around the roster.

 

[MattB]

Beretta 92FS. It’s not the most compact, but it’s reliable, accurate, not terribly expensive, and with a few Langdon parts will have a spectacular trigger.

 

[bcj68]

No one for the HK P2000???

OK..seriously for a striker gun the M&P 2.0 line is hard to bead...so far I'm up to a M&P 2.0 compact, full size, 10mm, Shield Plus, and Shield X...

Would love to get into the Echelon or the VP9...

 

[Wolkenflieger]

Springfield eschelon. I have or have had every roster 9mm and I can confidently say overall the eschelon 4.0 is my favorite. That being said I think the answer to the question depends on the persons likes, priorities and purpose

*Echelon

 

[pancakes]

*Echelon

i have a lisp

 

[Deleted member 16735]

Beretta 92FS. It’s not the most compact, but it’s reliable, accurate, not terribly expensive, and with a few Langdon parts will have a spectacular trigger.

2 major strikes against it though, non removable front sight and very difficult/expensive/janky to put an optic. If they sold the modern optic ready versions it would be a fantastic option.